โ€บNavigation

Iteration 84 โ€” H-072 MRP EXCLUDED ยท B-04 CLOSES KILL #25 ยท BATCH CLOSED 12/12: 2 ADMITS ยท 10 KILLS

In plain words: the batch's last candidate won the fight everyone was watching and lost to a technicality that isn't one. Against the certified flip counter โ€” the fight its dossier flagged from birth โ€” its worst-regime floor reading proved genuinely different (9% overlap, a decisive win). But when the same reading was recomputed on a slightly smaller data sample, the feature ranking reshuffled wholesale (74% agreement, far under the 90% bar). The reason is structural: a MINIMUM is set by whichever single regime happens to score lowest, and with noisy estimates, different samples crown different worst-regimes โ€” the same disease that killed the tail-variance candidate, in minimum's clothing. The boneyard entry says out loud: a noise-controlled floor (a soft minimum) would be genuinely worth building, because the orthogonality is real. With that, batch B-04 closes twelve-for-twelve: TWO certificates (both distance geometries โ€” the boundary that rested on one instrument now has three) and TEN kills, each by a different named mechanism โ€” a taxonomy of how instruments fail, built one honest execution at a time.

Preflight (A0): 2026-07-10 20:25 โ€” load1 3.77/32c (steady) ยท no heavy nasimubd jobs ยท 35 GiB avail, si/so=0 ยท all four services active โ†’ ALL PASS. Sync: main up-to-date, worktree 0 behind. One capped run (0.34 min), readonly=2 loader, deterministic.

M3 census โ€” how it resolved (mrp_m3_census.py, 123/123)

CheckReadingRuling
k_v incumbent shadow (the watched fight)ฯ = 0.092 โ€” the floor is genuinely NOT the flip counter in disguise; the COVERED-PARTIAL worry dissolvedWON
Mean-profile adjacency ยท stack grid0.843 ยท worst 0.639 (HSIC-X closest)CLEAR
NSUB dial law (THE KILL)ฯ(mrp@1000, mrp@1500) = 0.735 < 0.90 โ€” different subsamples crown different argmin windows; the ranking reshuffles wholesaleFAIL
MechanismExtreme statistics inherit the noise of their arg-extreme โ€” third sighting (max-switch row 83 ยท max-null row 87 ยท min-floor here)STRUCTURAL
Verdict (row 95)EXCLUDE(subsample-fragile) โ€” KILL #25, BONEYARD #40 ยท re-proposal door open: a variance-controlled soft-min is worth building โ€” the k_v-orthogonality is real

B-04 closed โ€” the batch record

FateCandidates
2 ADMITsH-073 MMD (#13, thin-margin, row 80) ยท H-075 Wasserstein (#14, clean 4.0ร— beyond-null, row 86) โ€” the FRAGILEโ†”CONDITIONAL boundary went from k_v-alone to three instruments
10 kills, ten mechanismssame-witness echo (H-056) ยท tail-variance blind gauge (H-074) ยท sibling redundancy (H-038) ยท between-regime blindness (H-071) ยท surrogate unmasking (H-049) ยท door law ร—2 (H-068/H-069) ยท novelty-without-value (H-070) ยท estimation-noise gauge (H-044) ยท extreme-statistic dial fragility (H-072)
Side harvestMechanism data #5โ€“#7 โ†’ the inverted-mechanism investigation is proposal-ready (row 92)

โ–ถ Next iteration

Iteration 84 ยท 2026-07-10 ยท VERDICT (row 95) โ€” EXCLUDE ยท kill #25 ยท boneyard #40 ยท B-04 CLOSED 12/12 ยท capped (0.34 min) ยท readonly=2 ยท zero generated values ยท append-only ยท evidence: mrp_m3_census.py ยท mrp_m3_census_results.json