# PRODUCTION READINESS REPORT

**Audit ID:** TASK-000A  
**Date:** 2026-06-21  
**Scale:** 0–100 per dimension

---

## Scoring Rubric

| Score | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 90–100 | Production-ready, no blockers |
| 70–89 | Mostly ready, minor gaps |
| 50–69 | Functional but significant gaps |
| 30–49 | Early stage, core missing pieces |
| 0–29 | Pre-alpha, critical components absent |

---

## Dimension Scores

### Architecture: 62/100

**Strengths:**
- 17-category taxonomy is coherent and well-designed
- Static markdown-as-CMS is intentional and appropriate for scale
- Skill versioning system (v1/v2/v3) is clear and enforced
- JSON/YAML export API provides programmatic access

**Gaps:**
- `data/SKILLS_GRAPH.json` is a placeholder — graph layer does not exist
- `paths/` is empty — learning track architecture unimplemented
- `docs/index.html` is a 40KB monolith (documented technical debt)
- CLI architecture is planned but not implemented

---

### Code: 48/100

**Strengths:**
- `tools/` Python scripts are functional (`check_skill_quality.py`, `export_skills.py`)
- `pyproject.toml` and `requirements.txt` are real and pinned
- `tests/` directory exists

**Gaps:**
- Test coverage is unknown — no coverage report found
- CLI package (`skills_tree/`) not yet built
- PyPI publication not attempted
- `docs/index.html` has no build pipeline (raw file edits)
- Some workflow overlaps create maintenance risk

---

### Documentation: 72/100

**Strengths:**
- `README.md` is comprehensive (17KB)
- `CONTRIBUTING.md` is detailed (8.8KB)
- `PROJECT_MEMORY.md` is the most thorough project document (48KB)
- 10 localized README translations
- `meta/skill-template.md` is production-quality

**Gaps:**
- No `ARCHITECTURE.md`
- No per-category `README.md` files (17 missing)
- No onboarding "5-minute quickstart" for contributors
- API documentation sparse

---

### Governance: 18/100

**Critical finding:** This is the most broken dimension.

**Gaps (all critical):**
- `MEMORY_STATE.md` = placeholder (18 bytes)
- `DECISION_LOG.md` = placeholder (24 bytes)
- `AGENT_SKILLS_MASTER_PLAN.md` = placeholder (23 bytes)
- `AGENT_SKILLS_BACKLOG.md` = placeholder (19 bytes)
- All TASK reports = placeholders
- `PROJECT_CONSTITUTION.md` = missing
- `GRAPH_DIFF_PLAN.md` = missing
- No verified baseline existed until this audit

**Partial credit:** `PROJECT_MEMORY.md` contains a real, detailed backlog (Sections 5, 15) and serves as a de facto governance document.

---

### Testing: 22/100

**Gaps:**
- `tests/` exists but content and coverage are unknown
- No CI badge for test pass rate
- Skill quality validation exists (CI) but unit test coverage of tooling scripts is unknown
- No benchmark automation beyond 4 static benchmark documents
- OSV/Gitleaks security scanning is operational (positive signal)

---

### Security: 74/100

**Strengths:**
- Gitleaks configuration (`.gitleaks.toml`, 1.9KB)
- OSV.dev 15-minute CVE polling
- `osv-scanner.toml` configured
- Dependabot enabled
- `SECURITY.md` exists (7.1KB)

**Gaps:**
- No authentication layer (N/A for static site, but CLI will need token management)
- Phantom badge window is an accepted known limitation

---

### Distribution: 15/100

**Gaps:**
- CLI not on PyPI
- No GitHub Release packages (zip of skill index)
- Not listed in LangChain Hub, MCP registry, or OpenAI Cookbook
- No npm package
- Framework integrations = 0
- GitHub Stars = unknown (PROJECT_MEMORY: "Unknown")

**Partial credit:** GitHub Pages is live; static JSON/YAML API is accessible.

---

## Overall Score

| Dimension | Weight | Score | Weighted |
|---|---|---|---|
| Architecture | 20% | 62 | 12.4 |
| Code | 20% | 48 | 9.6 |
| Documentation | 15% | 72 | 10.8 |
| Governance | 20% | 18 | 3.6 |
| Testing | 10% | 22 | 2.2 |
| Security | 10% | 74 | 7.4 |
| Distribution | 5% | 15 | 0.75 |
| **TOTAL** | **100%** | | **46.75 → 47/100** |

---

## Production Readiness: **47/100 — Early Stage**

The core content corpus (377 skills, CI/CD, schema validation) is production-quality. The governance layer, graph layer, and distribution layer are not functional. This project should be considered **content-production-ready** but **not product-ready**.

---

## Critical Blockers to Production

1. **`data/SKILLS_GRAPH.json` is a placeholder** — graph feature cannot function
2. **All governance files are placeholders** — cannot track decisions, state, or task history
3. **CLI not published** — programmatic access blocked
4. **80% stub ratio** — content quality problem undermines trust
5. **`paths/` is empty** — no learning tracks for users
