# POST-REMEDIATION CONSISTENCY CHECK

**Audit ID:** PRCC-001  
**Date:** 2026-07-05  
**Triggered by:** CORPUS-002 CAP-ID remediation commit  
**Scope:** All corpus entries and ontology files in skills-tree  

---

## Capability Consistency

### Before Fix (pre-remediation state)

| File | CAP-009 name | CAP-014 name | Consistent with ontology? |
|---|---|---|---|
| capability_ontology.json | chain_of_thought_reasoning | tool_execution | ✅ Authoritative |
| CORPUS-001 | chain_of_thought_reasoning | tool_execution | ✅ Consistent |
| CORPUS-002 | **tool_execution** | **planning_and_decomposition** | ❌ 2 collisions |
| CORPUS_ANALYSIS_V1.md | tool_execution (derived) | planning_and_decomposition (derived) | ❌ Inherited |

**Pre-remediation collision count: 2 (both in CORPUS-002)**

### After Fix (post-remediation state)

| File | CAP-014 name | CAP-010 name | CAP-009 name | Consistent with ontology? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| capability_ontology.json | tool_execution | planning_and_decomposition | chain_of_thought_reasoning | ✅ Authoritative |
| CORPUS-001 | tool_execution | planning_and_decomposition | chain_of_thought_reasoning | ✅ Consistent |
| CORPUS-002 | **tool_execution** | **planning_and_decomposition** | (not used) | ✅ Consistent |
| CORPUS_ANALYSIS_V1.md | tool_execution | planning_and_decomposition | chain_of_thought_reasoning | ✅ Regenerated |

**Post-remediation collision count: 0 (CORPUS-002)**

---

## Validation Results

### 1. Schema Validity

| Entry | Required Fields Present | $schema declared | $version declared | PASS/FAIL |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CORPUS-001 | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | **PASS** |
| CORPUS-002 | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | **PASS** |

### 2. Ontology Reference Validation

Every cap_id in every corpus entry checked against capability_ontology.json (SHA: 5cdcd58d).

**CORPUS-001 capability references:**

| cap_id | name in corpus | name in ontology | Match? |
|---|---|---|---|
| CAP-001 | text_understanding | text_understanding | ✅ |
| CAP-002 | document_parsing | document_parsing | ✅ |
| CAP-003 | intent_classification | intent_classification | ✅ |
| CAP-005 | short_term_context_management | short_term_context_management | ✅ |
| CAP-006 | long_term_memory_storage | long_term_memory_storage | ✅ |
| CAP-007 | semantic_retrieval | semantic_retrieval | ✅ |
| CAP-008 | episodic_memory | episodic_memory | ✅ |
| CAP-009 | chain_of_thought_reasoning | chain_of_thought_reasoning | ✅ |
| CAP-010 | planning_and_decomposition | planning_and_decomposition | ✅ |
| CAP-011 | self_evaluation | self_evaluation | ✅ |
| CAP-012 | hypothesis_generation | hypothesis_generation | ✅ |
| CAP-013 | tool_selection | tool_selection | ✅ |
| CAP-014 | tool_execution | tool_execution | ✅ |
| CAP-017 | response_generation | response_generation | ✅ |
| CAP-018 | multi_turn_dialogue_management | multi_turn_dialogue_management | ✅ |
| CAP-019 | structured_output_generation | structured_output_generation | ✅ |
| CAP-020 | summarization | summarization | ✅ |
| CAP-021 | task_orchestration | task_orchestration | ✅ |
| CAP-022 | error_recovery | error_recovery | ✅ |
| CAP-023 | human_in_loop_escalation | human_in_loop_escalation | ✅ |
| CAP-024 | multi_agent_coordination | multi_agent_coordination | ✅ |
| CAP-025 | pii_detection_and_redaction | pii_detection_and_redaction | ✅ |
| CAP-026 | hallucination_detection | hallucination_detection | ✅ |
| CAP-027 | compliance_logging | compliance_logging | ✅ |
| CAP-028 | output_validation | output_validation | ✅ |

**CORPUS-001 result: 25/25 references valid. PASS.**

**CORPUS-002 capability references (post-remediation):**

| cap_id | name in corpus | name in ontology | Match? |
|---|---|---|---|
| CAP-001 | text_understanding | text_understanding | ✅ |
| CAP-003 | intent_classification | intent_classification | ✅ |
| CAP-005 | short_term_context_management | short_term_context_management | ✅ |
| CAP-006 | long_term_memory_storage | long_term_memory_storage | ✅ |
| CAP-007 | semantic_retrieval | semantic_retrieval | ✅ |
| CAP-008 | episodic_memory | episodic_memory | ✅ |
| CAP-010 | planning_and_decomposition | planning_and_decomposition | ✅ |
| CAP-011 | self_evaluation | self_evaluation | ✅ |
| CAP-014 | tool_execution | tool_execution | ✅ |
| CAP-017 | response_generation | response_generation | ✅ |
| CAP-026 | hallucination_detection | hallucination_detection | ✅ |
| CAP-028 | output_validation | output_validation | ✅ |

**CORPUS-002 result: 12/12 references valid. PASS.**

### 3. Goal Mapping Validation

| Entry | goal_id | goal_class | goal_class valid? |
|---|---|---|---|
| CORPUS-001 | GOAL-001 | reactive_agent | ✅ |
| CORPUS-002 | GOAL-002 | reactive_agent | ✅ |

### 4. Evaluation Mapping Validation

Each evaluation_requirement.capability field checked against the entry's own required_capabilities cap_ids.

**CORPUS-002 evaluation references:**

| Evaluation capability | Present in required_capabilities? |
|---|---|
| CAP-003 | ✅ |
| CAP-014 | ✅ (was CAP-009 pre-remediation — now corrected) |
| CAP-028 | ✅ |
| CAP-006 | ✅ |
| CAP-011 | ✅ |
| CAP-017 | ✅ |
| CAP-010 | ✅ (was CAP-014 pre-remediation — now corrected) |

**All 7 evaluation references resolve to declared capabilities. PASS.**

### 5. Dependency Order Validation

**CORPUS-002 dependency_order (post-remediation):**  
`[CAP-001, CAP-003, CAP-005, CAP-006, CAP-007, CAP-014, CAP-011, CAP-010, CAP-017, CAP-026, CAP-028, CAP-008]`

- All 12 entries present in required_capabilities: ✅
- No duplicates: ✅
- No cap_ids in dependency_order absent from required_capabilities: ✅

**PASS.**

### 6. Duplicate Capability Check

| Entry | Duplicate cap_ids? | Count of unique cap_ids | Count of declared capabilities |
|---|---|---|---|
| CORPUS-001 | None | 25 | 25 |
| CORPUS-002 | None | 12 | 12 |

**No duplicates introduced. PASS.**

### 7. Orphan Capability Check

All cap_ids in dependency_order are present in required_capabilities. No cap_ids appear in required_capabilities that are absent from dependency_order.

| Entry | Orphans found? |
|---|---|
| CORPUS-001 | None |
| CORPUS-002 | None |

**PASS.**

---

## Remaining Collisions

### Type A — Corpus vs Capability Ontology

**Count: 0**

All corpus entries now resolve 100% of cap_ids to matching names in capability_ontology.json.

### Type B — Evaluation Ontology vs Capability Ontology (pre-existing, out of scope)

**Count: 2**

| CAP-ID | capability_ontology name | evaluation_ontology name | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| CAP-023 | human_in_loop_escalation | structured_data_generation | ⚠️ Unresolved — requires RCA-002 |
| CAP-025 | pii_detection_and_redaction | multi_modal_understanding | ⚠️ Unresolved — requires RCA-002 |

These collisions exist in evaluation_ontology.json only. They do not affect CORPUS-001 or CORPUS-002 because neither corpus entry references CAP-023 or CAP-025 with conflicting names. Frozen pending RCA-002.

### Type C — Missing Prerequisite Dependencies

**Count: 2 (pre-existing, informational)**

| Cap requiring | Missing prerequisite | In ontology? | In any corpus entry? |
|---|---|---|---|
| CAP-014 | CAP-013 (tool_selection) | ✅ | ❌ Not declared in CORPUS-002 |
| CAP-028 | CAP-019 (structured_output_generation) | ✅ | ❌ Not declared in CORPUS-002 |

These are corpus completeness gaps, not ID collisions. Not blocking.

### Type D — Evaluation Ontology Missing Mappings

**Count: 3 (pre-existing, informational)**

CAP-014, CAP-006, CAP-011, CAP-010 have corpus evaluation requirements but no evaluation_ontology mapping. Not blocking for corpus integrity.

---

## Repository Integrity Status

```
PASS
```

| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| Schema validity — all corpus entries | PASS |
| Ontology reference validity — CORPUS-001 (25/25) | PASS |
| Ontology reference validity — CORPUS-002 (12/12) | PASS |
| Goal mapping validity | PASS |
| Evaluation mapping validity — CORPUS-002 (7/7) | PASS |
| Dependency order validity | PASS |
| Duplicate capability check | PASS |
| Orphan capability check | PASS |
| Remaining Type A collisions | 0 |

**All corpus entries are consistent with capability_ontology.json (SHA: 5cdcd58d).**

---

*Audit generated 2026-07-05 post-remediation commit. Pre-remediation state had 2 Type A collisions in CORPUS-002. Post-remediation state: 0 Type A collisions.*
