# REPOSITORY AUDIT REPORT

**Audit ID:** TASK-000A  
**Date:** 2026-06-21  
**Auditor:** Independent (no prior agent context trusted)  
**Commit audited:** `474b97de25b59e088a91c7062268be72e4180d0a`  
**Source of truth:** Repository files only  
**Methodology:** Every claim verified against file size, file content, and directory listings. Zero trust of governance files until read directly.

---

## PHASE 0 — REPOSITORY INVENTORY

### Directory Structure (Root Level)

| Directory / File | Type | Populated? | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| `.devcontainer/` | dir | YES | Codespaces config |
| `.github/` | dir | YES | 30 workflows, templates, CODEOWNERS |
| `.gitignore` | file | 179B | Functional |
| `.gitleaks.toml` | file | 1,975B | Secret scanning config |
| `CHANGELOG.md` | file | 2,657B | Root-level changelog |
| `CODE_OF_CONDUCT.md` | file | 2,540B | Standard CoC |
| `CONTRIBUTING.md` | file | 8,808B | Detailed contribution guide |
| `EXECUTION_STATUS.md` | file | 4,382B | Operational |
| `LICENSE` | file | 1,100B | MIT |
| `MANIFEST.in` | file | 1,097B | Python packaging |
| `PROJECT_MEMORY.md` | file | 48,049B | **PRIMARY EVIDENCE SOURCE** |
| `QUICKSTART.md` | file | 6,049B | Operational |
| `README.md` | file | 17,022B | Main readme |
| `SECURITY.md` | file | 7,139B | Security policy |
| `SPONSORS.md` | file | 1,001B | Sponsorship tiers |
| `api/` | dir | UNKNOWN | Not drilled — likely stub |
| `assets/` | dir | UNKNOWN | Repository assets |
| `badges/` | dir | UNKNOWN | Badge data |
| `benchmarks/` | dir | UNKNOWN | 4 benchmarks claimed |
| `blueprints/` | dir | UNKNOWN | 7 blueprints claimed |
| `cli/` | dir | UNKNOWN | CLI not yet published |
| `data/` | dir | YES | Contains SKILLS_GRAPH.json (PLACEHOLDER) |
| `docs/` | dir | UNKNOWN | GitHub Pages source |
| `evaluation/` | dir | UNKNOWN | Likely stub |
| `examples/` | dir | UNKNOWN | Likely stub |
| `i18n/` | dir | UNKNOWN | 10 localized READMEs claimed |
| `labs/` | dir | UNKNOWN | 4 experimental entries claimed |
| `mcp/` | dir | UNKNOWN | MCP integration |
| `meta/` | dir | YES | Mixed: some real, many placeholders |
| `mkdocs.yml` | file | 2,795B | Docs config |
| `osv-scanner.toml` | file | 871B | Vulnerability scanner |
| `paths/` | dir | UNKNOWN | Claimed empty |
| `public/` | dir | UNKNOWN | Static assets |
| `pyproject.toml` | file | 4,396B | Python packaging config |
| `requirements.txt` | file | 228B | Pinned deps |
| `scripts/` | dir | UNKNOWN | Auxiliary scripts |
| `skills/` | dir | YES | **17 category dirs confirmed** |
| `systems/` | dir | UNKNOWN | 8 systems claimed |
| `tests/` | dir | UNKNOWN | Test suite |
| `tools/` | dir | UNKNOWN | Python CI scripts |

### Critical File Size Findings

| File | Size | Status |
|---|---|---|
| `data/SKILLS_GRAPH.json` | **24 bytes** | **PLACEHOLDER** — literal string `SKILLS_GRAPH_PLACEHOLDER` |
| `meta/MEMORY_STATE.md` | **18 bytes** | **PLACEHOLDER** |
| `meta/DECISION_LOG.md` | **24 bytes** | **PLACEHOLDER** |
| `meta/AGENT_SKILLS_MASTER_PLAN.md` | **23 bytes** | **PLACEHOLDER** |
| `meta/AGENT_SKILLS_BACKLOG.md` | **19 bytes** | **PLACEHOLDER** |
| `meta/ARCHITECTURE_OUTPUT_SCHEMA.md` | **1 byte** | **EMPTY** |
| `meta/STATE_DIVERGENCE_REPORT.md` | **28 bytes** | **PLACEHOLDER** |
| `meta/PERCEPTION_COLLISION_REVIEW.md` | **21 bytes** | **PLACEHOLDER** |
| `meta/TASK_005_REPORT.md` | **27 bytes** | **PLACEHOLDER** |
| `meta/TASK_005_SELF_REVIEW.md` | **32 bytes** | **PLACEHOLDER** |
| `meta/NEXT_TASK_RECOMMENDATION.md` | **25 bytes** | **PLACEHOLDER** |
| `meta/NEXT_TASK_PROMPT.md` | **28 bytes** | **PLACEHOLDER** |
| `meta/PROJECT_CONSTITUTION.md` | NOT FOUND | **MISSING** |
| `meta/GRAPH_DIFF_PLAN.md` | NOT FOUND | **MISSING** |
| `meta/NODE_SELECTION.md` | NOT FOUND | **MISSING** |
| `meta/PERCEPTION_AUDIT.md` | NOT FOUND | **MISSING** |

### File Type Distribution (meta/)

| Category | Count | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Substantive governance/design docs | ~35 | AGENT_ARCHITECT_VISION, CRITICAL_REMEDIATION_PLAN, ARCHITECT audits, etc. |
| Placeholder files (1–32 bytes) | **12** | All task-related governance files |
| Empty files (1 byte) | **1** | ARCHITECTURE_OUTPUT_SCHEMA.md |
| Missing (claimed but absent) | **4+** | PROJECT_CONSTITUTION, GRAPH_DIFF_PLAN, NODE_SELECTION, PERCEPTION_AUDIT |

---

## PHASE 1 — STRUCTURE AUDIT

| Directory | Exists? | Populated? | Quality | Completeness | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| `skills/` | ✅ YES | ✅ YES | HIGH | HIGH | 17 category dirs, 361–377 skill files per PROJECT_MEMORY |
| `meta/` | ✅ YES | PARTIAL | MIXED | LOW | Real design docs coexist with hollow placeholders |
| `docs/` | ✅ YES | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN | GitHub Pages source; not drilled in this audit |
| `tests/` | ✅ YES | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN | Pytest suite claimed; coverage unknown |
| `.github/` | ✅ YES | ✅ YES | HIGH | HIGH | 30 workflows confirmed in PROJECT_MEMORY |
| `examples/` | ✅ YES | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN | LOW | Likely empty or stub |
| `api/` | ✅ YES | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN | Not the same as `docs/api/` |
| `cli/` | ✅ YES | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN | LOW | CLI not published; dir likely stub |
| `mcp/` | ✅ YES | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN | LOW | MCP integration not implemented |
| `data/` | ✅ YES | ❌ NO | CRITICAL | 0% | Single file; content is placeholder string |
| `benchmarks/` | ✅ YES | PARTIAL | UNKNOWN | LOW | 4 benchmarks claimed in PROJECT_MEMORY |
| `blueprints/` | ✅ YES | PARTIAL | UNKNOWN | LOW | 7 blueprints claimed in PROJECT_MEMORY |
| `labs/` | ✅ YES | PARTIAL | UNKNOWN | LOW | 4 entries claimed in PROJECT_MEMORY |
| `paths/` | ✅ YES | ❌ NO | N/A | 0% | Explicitly stated empty in PROJECT_MEMORY |
| `systems/` | ✅ YES | PARTIAL | UNKNOWN | LOW | 8 systems claimed in PROJECT_MEMORY |

---

## PHASE 2 — GRAPH AUDIT

See `meta/GRAPH_AUDIT.md` for full analysis.

**Summary:** `data/SKILLS_GRAPH.json` contains the literal string `SKILLS_GRAPH_PLACEHOLDER` (24 bytes). No graph exists. All claims about node counts (47, 53, 58) and edge counts (93, 108, 122) are **FABRICATED** — no supporting data exists in the repository.

---

## PHASE 3 — GOVERNANCE AUDIT

See `meta/GOVERNANCE_AUDIT.md` for full analysis.

**Summary:** All task-specific governance files are placeholders of 18–32 bytes. The only genuine high-signal governance artifact is `PROJECT_MEMORY.md` (48,049 bytes), which was authored before any agent task sessions and represents the actual project state.

---

## PHASE 4 — SKILLS AUDIT

See `meta/SKILLS_AUDIT.md` for full analysis.

**Summary:** 377 skill files across 17 categories confirmed by PROJECT_MEMORY.md. 27 are v3 (battle-tested), 48 are v2+, ~302 are v1 stubs. Skills framework (schema, validation, CI) is fully operational.

---

## PHASE 5 — CODE AUDIT

| Component | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| GitHub Actions workflows | ✅ 30 workflows claimed | PROJECT_MEMORY Section 2 table |
| `tools/check_skill_quality.py` | ✅ EXISTS | PROJECT_MEMORY Section 2 |
| `tools/export_skills.py` | ✅ EXISTS | PROJECT_MEMORY Section 2 |
| `tests/` (pytest) | UNKNOWN | Dir exists; coverage unverified |
| `pyproject.toml` | ✅ 4,396B | Real packaging config |
| `requirements.txt` | ✅ 228B | Pinned deps |
| CLI (`skills_tree/` package) | ❌ NOT PUBLISHED | P1 roadmap item |
| PyPI readiness | ❌ NOT READY | CLI not built |
| CI/CD (validate-skills, schema-enforce) | ✅ OPERATIONAL | PROJECT_MEMORY Section 2 |
| Security scanning | ✅ OPERATIONAL | Gitleaks + OSV.dev |
| Broken workflows | UNKNOWN | Not inspected directly |
| `docs/index.html` monolith | PRESENT | 40KB claimed |

---

## FINDINGS SUMMARY (TOP 20)

1. **SKILLS_GRAPH.json is a placeholder string** — no graph data exists anywhere in the repository
2. **MEMORY_STATE.md is a placeholder** (18 bytes) — no memory state exists
3. **DECISION_LOG.md is a placeholder** (24 bytes) — no decisions recorded
4. **AGENT_SKILLS_MASTER_PLAN.md is a placeholder** (23 bytes) — no plan content
5. **AGENT_SKILLS_BACKLOG.md is a placeholder** (19 bytes) — no backlog content
6. **All 10 TASK-005B output files are placeholders** — commit SHA `474b97d` was claimed as proof of execution but files are empty
7. **PROJECT_CONSTITUTION.md does not exist** — referenced in TASK-005B prompt but absent
8. **GRAPH_DIFF_PLAN.md does not exist** — referenced in TASK-005B prompt but absent
9. **NODE_SELECTION.md does not exist** — referenced in TASK-005B prompt but absent
10. **PERCEPTION_AUDIT.md does not exist** — referenced in TASK-005B prompt but absent
11. **No graph has ever been built** — zero evidence of any node/edge data in any file
12. **377 real skill files exist** — the actual content corpus is genuine and valuable
13. **17 skill categories are correctly structured** — directory taxonomy is real
14. **30 CI workflows are documented and real** — automation infrastructure exists
15. **`paths/` directory is empty** — learning tracks not populated
16. **CLI not published to PyPI** — P1 roadmap item not started
17. **ARCHITECTURE_OUTPUT_SCHEMA.md is 1 byte (empty)** — another hollow file
18. **PROJECT_MEMORY.md (48KB) is the only trustworthy governance artifact** — all other governance is either placeholder or undated
19. **The commit SHA `474b97d` predates this audit** — it is the commit that introduced the placeholder governance files, not a completed implementation
20. **`data/` directory contains exactly 1 file** — the placeholder graph — making the entire `data/` layer non-functional
