# ChatGPT Strategic Decision Summary

**Date**: 2026-06-14  
**Session**: https://chatgpt.com/c/6a2e6ab5-cd60-83ea-a549-48f40a545a1e  
**Role**: Chief Product Architect / CTO  
**Coordinator**: Autonomous Coordination Agent (Perplexity)

---

## Executive Summary

ChatGPT provided strategic direction to pivot Skills Tree from a passive "skill catalog" to an active **"AI Engineering Operating System"** centered on the **Agent Skill Architect** tool. This decision represents a fundamental shift in product strategy, prioritizing user-facing orchestration capabilities over content expansion.

---

## Core Strategic Decisions

### 1. Strategic Pivot: Catalog → Operating System

**Decision**: Reposition Skills Tree as an AI Engineering Operating System that maps, validates, composes, and operationalizes AI agent capabilities.

**Rationale**:
- Current positioning as "skill catalog" is passive and commodity-like
- Users need tools to **use** skills, not just browse them
- Operating System framing elevates value proposition
- Creates defensible moat through orchestration layer

**Impact**:
- ✅ **EXECUTED**: README.md updated with new positioning (commit d4aed8f)
- Brand identity now emphasizes 4 core functions: map, validate, compose, operationalize
- Shift from "content repository" to "build-time infrastructure"

---

### 2. Product Priority: Build Agent Skill Architect

**Decision**: Make "Agent Skill Architect" the flagship product feature, ahead of all content expansion work.

**What It Is**:
An interactive tool that allows users to:
1. Input a goal (e.g., "Build a local legal agent using MCP")
2. Receive a complete architecture with:
   - Required skills from Skills Tree
   - Dependency mapping
   - Framework recommendations (LangChain, AutoGen, etc.)
   - Risk analysis (production-ready vs. experimental)
   - Export as JSON blueprint + implementation docs

**MVP Scope (2 weeks)**:
- Interactive skill selector with search/filter
- Drag-and-drop skill composition
- Basic validation (missing critical skills)
- Export as JSON blueprint

**Rationale**:
- Transforms Skills Tree from **reference** → **tool**
- Addresses real user pain: "How do I actually build this?"
- Creates viral loop: users share blueprints → drive traffic
- Differentiates from competitors (everyone has skill docs; nobody has skill architect)

**Impact**:
- ✅ **SPEC CREATED**: `meta/AGENT_SKILL_ARCHITECT_MVP.md` (commit 931e93b)
- Defines vision, technical approach, success metrics
- Ready for Wave 1 implementation

---

### 3. Execution Priority Reordering

**Decision**: Deprioritize content expansion (stub upgrades) in favor of tooling and distribution.

**New Priority Order**:
1. **Agent Skill Architect** (P0 - builds the OS)
2. **CLI + PyPI** (P0 - programmatic access)
3. **MCP Registry** (P0 - distribution channel)
4. **Semantic Search** (P1 - discovery)
5. **Framework Matrix** (P1 - integration guidance)
6. Stub Upgrades (P2 - content quality)

**Rationale**:
- 51 battle-tested skills are sufficient for MVP
- Tools unlock exponentially more value than content
- Distribution (CLI, MCP) drives adoption faster than quality
- Content can scale via community once tools exist

**Impact on ROADMAP_V2.md**:
- Wave 1 (Content Quality) → DEPRIORITIZED to Wave 5
- New Wave 0 inserted: Strategic Identity + Agent Skill Architect
- Waves reordered by strategic impact, not content volume

---

### 4. Architecture Design Requirement

**Decision**: Before implementing Agent Skill Architect, create detailed architecture spec in `AGENT_ARCHITECT_VISION.md`.

**Required Contents**:
- User journeys (3-5 personas)
- System design (data flow, architecture diagrams)
- Data source mapping (how skills → blueprints)
- Multi-stage MVP scopes:
  - 2-week MVP: Basic selector + export
  - 30-day MVP: Visual canvas + validation
  - 90-day MVP: LLM recommendations + community blueprints

**Rationale**:
- Prevents "build first, design later" anti-pattern
- Forces clarity on technical approach before coding
- Creates alignment document for multi-agent coordination

**Impact**:
- ⚠️ **PARTIALLY COMPLETE**: `AGENT_SKILL_ARCHITECT_MVP.md` covers this partially
- Missing: Detailed user journeys and system diagrams
- **RECOMMENDED**: Expand MVP doc or create separate VISION doc

---

### 5. Multi-Agent Coordination Framework

**Decision**: Establish explicit roles for AI agents in execution workflow.

**Agent Roles**:
- **ChatGPT**: CTO / Product Architect (strategic decisions, roadmap)
- **Perplexity**: Research & Validation (challenge assumptions, audit reality)
- **Claude Code**: Implementation (write code, execute tasks)
- **GitHub Repository**: Source of Truth (planning docs are single source)

**Workflow**:
1. ChatGPT makes strategic decision
2. Perplexity validates against repository state
3. Perplexity creates coordination docs (CHATGPT_DECISION.md, VALIDATION_REPORT.md)
4. Claude Code implements one task at a time
5. Perplexity audits results and updates planning docs

**Critical Rule**: **Never allow circular hallucination** (AI feeding AI without human validation)

**Rationale**:
- Prevents "infinite loop" of AI agents making work for each other
- Ensures human-in-the-loop for strategic decisions
- Creates audit trail via GitHub commit history
- Separates concerns: strategy vs. validation vs. execution

**Impact**:
- ✅ **IN PROGRESS**: This document (CHATGPT_DECISION.md) establishes pattern
- Next: Create VALIDATION_REPORT.md comparing decisions against repository state

---

## Roadmap Updates

### Before ChatGPT Consultation

**Focus**: Content expansion (upgrade 302 stubs to v2)

**Priority Order**:
1. Wave 1: Content Quality (upgrade top 50 skills)
2. Wave 2: Catalog Expansion (upgrade next 100 skills)
3. Wave 3: Programmatic Distribution (CLI, MCP)
4. Wave 4: Learning Paths
5. Wave 5: Catalog Completion (remaining 152 skills)

### After ChatGPT Consultation

**Focus**: Tooling and orchestration (Agent Skill Architect)

**Priority Order**:
1. **Wave 0**: Strategic Identity + Agent Skill Architect spec ✅ COMPLETE
2. **Wave 1**: Agent Skill Architect MVP implementation
3. **Wave 2**: CLI + PyPI distribution
4. **Wave 3**: MCP Registry + LangChain Hub integration
5. **Wave 4**: Semantic Search + Framework Matrix
6. Wave 5: Content expansion (deprioritized)

---

## Task Priorities

### Immediate (Next Sprint)

**T-05: Agent Skill Architect MVP** (ROI: 47/50)
- Set up Next.js project in `tools/architect/`
- Build interactive skill selector (search/filter)
- Add skill composition canvas
- Implement JSON blueprint export
- Deploy to GitHub Pages
- **Estimated**: 2 weeks

### High Priority (Month 1)

**T-XX: CLI Tool** (ROI: TBD)
- Build `skills-tree` CLI with Python
- Commands: `search`, `view`, `blueprint`, `validate`
- Publish to PyPI
- **Estimated**: 1 week

**T-XX: MCP Registry Integration** (ROI: TBD)
- Package top 10 battle-tested skills as MCP servers
- Submit to Model Context Protocol registry
- **Estimated**: 3 days

### Medium Priority (Month 2-3)

**T-XX: Semantic Search** (ROI: TBD)
- Implement natural language search ("find skills for PDF parsing")
- Use vector embeddings (OpenAI/local)
- **Estimated**: 1 week

**T-XX: Framework Matrix** (ROI: TBD)
- Add "Works with" badges (LangChain, AutoGen, CrewAI, etc.)
- Create integration examples
- **Estimated**: 3 days

---

## Architecture Changes

### New Directory Structure

```
skills-tree/
├── tools/
│   └── architect/          # NEW: Agent Skill Architect web app
│       ├── src/
│       ├── public/
│       ├── package.json
│       └── README.md
├── cli/                    # NEW: Python CLI tool
│   ├── skills_tree/
│   ├── setup.py
│   └── README.md
├── meta/
│   ├── CHATGPT_DECISION.md      # NEW: This file
│   ├── VALIDATION_REPORT.md     # NEW: Coordination validation
│   ├── AGENT_SKILL_ARCHITECT_MVP.md  # ✅ Created
│   └── WAVE_0_COMPLETION.md     # ✅ Created
└── blueprints/             # EXISTING: Already has 7 production blueprints
```

### Technical Stack

**Agent Skill Architect**:
- Framework: Next.js 14 (App Router)
- UI: React + Tailwind CSS
- Data: Static JSON from `skills/**/*.json` + `meta/graph.json`
- Deployment: GitHub Pages
- Canvas: React Flow (drag-and-drop composition)

**CLI Tool**:
- Language: Python 3.9+
- Package Manager: Poetry
- Distribution: PyPI
- Dependencies: Click, Rich, Requests

---

## Comparison Against Repository Truth

See `meta/VALIDATION_REPORT.md` for detailed conflict analysis.

**Key Findings**:
1. ✅ Wave 0 execution aligns with ChatGPT decisions
2. ⚠️ PROJECT_MEMORY.md still reflects old priorities (content-first)
3. ⚠️ ROADMAP_V2.md needs reordering to reflect tool-first strategy
4. ✅ AGENT_SKILL_ARCHITECT_MVP.md successfully captures vision
5. ✅ Blueprints library already exists (no work needed)

---

## Next Task

**Coordinator Action**: Create `meta/VALIDATION_REPORT.md`

**Developer Action**: Implement T-05 (Agent Skill Architect MVP)

**Timeline**: Start Week of June 17, 2026

---

## Audit Trail

- **ChatGPT Session**: https://chatgpt.com/c/6a2e6ab5-cd60-83ea-a549-48f40a545a1e
- **Decision Date**: 2026-06-14
- **Coordinator**: Perplexity (Autonomous Coordination Agent)
- **Repository Commits**: d4aed8f, 931e93b, b2a5ef5
- **Status**: Decisions captured ✅ | Validation pending ⚠️ | Implementation pending 📋
